May 5, 2009

Cass Sunstein and “Net Neutrality”

Posted in Law tagged , , , , , at 1:59 pm by Andrew

In my previous posts on why I think Cass Sunstein will be Barack Obama’s nominee to the Supreme Court to replace outgoing Justice David Souter, two separate commenters mentioned net neutrality as a reason to oppose a Sunstein nomination.

Three things:

1) Sunstein isn’t my personal top choice; that would be Sunstein protege Diane Wood, who has the strongest record of unambiguously supporting strict separation of church and state. Sunstein was just the first name that popped into my head when the news broke, and I was — and am! — surprised that he doesn’t seem to be getting any sort of attention from the Jeffrey Toobins and Chuck Todds of the world. So far I have not seen a single mainstream media mention of Sunstein as a potential nominee, and that strikes me as seriously underrating his chances.

2) On the issues: Sunstein explicitly mentioned net neutrality as a reason he was voting for Obama back in the Democratic primaries in his 2008 endorsement:

He [Obama] proposes a $150 billion research budget for climate change. He wants to hold an unprecedented national auction for the right to emit greenhouse gases. He has offered an ambitious plan for promoting technological innovation, calling for a national broadband policy, embracing network neutrality, and proposing a reform of the patent system.

[emphasis added]

That seems pretty clear to me.

3) In the alternative, if you think Sunstein is secretly opposed to net neutrality as a matter of public policy, you should be rooting for his appointment to the Supreme Court and away from the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, where any such policies will actually be enacted over the next few years.

About these ads

9 Comments »

    • Andrew said,

      Oh, darn. Still, when Sunstein is the nominee, remember that you read it here FIRST. :)

      • John Huey said,

        I’m prepared to be surprised but I think that Obama will go for a woman and/or minority. Of course, what I would dearly love to see is for Obama to have the opportunity to replace Scalia!!!!! :)

      • John Huey said,

        Well, Intrade.com gives Sunstein low chances:

        http://www.intrade.com/jsp/intrade/contractSearch/#

        In fact, you’ll notice that Wood is trading at a higher price than Sunstein.

      • John Huey said,

        Oops. The link doesn’t go directly to the Supreme Court market. When it opens, just click on ‘Legal’ and then on the ‘Supreme Court’ .

  1. notscarednew said,

    ioRead up on something else left by the Bush Administration still going on in Austin, TX.io
    They left a weapon for the police department in Austin, TX to torture and violate people’s rights without anyone knowing.

  2. Phil said,

    In the alternative, if you think Sunstein is secretly opposed to net neutrality as a matter of public policy, you should be rooting for his appointment to the Supreme Court and away from the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs,

    No, you should not be rooting for fascists at all.

    • Andrew said,

      What, exactly, is your evidence that Cass Sunstein is a “fascist?”

  3. phil said,

    He wants the government to intrude, manipulate, and set various restrictions on online communication. That’s fascistic. Not to mention, he apparently thinks drafting torture memos is OK.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 32 other followers

%d bloggers like this: